NBC Bay Area /

News

Voters Choose Not to Legalize Prostitution in San Francisco Pols argued prostitution brings drugs, violence to neighborhoods

Updated 11:06 PM PDT, Tue, Nov 4, 2008

Getty Images

A suporter of Yes on K wears a campaign sticker during a Yes on K news conference October 29, 2008 in San Francisco, California. San Francisco ballot measure Proposition K seeks to stop enforcement of laws targeting prostitution.

 

San Franciscans rejected a measure that would have legalized prostitution in the city.

Measure K lost by an overwhelming majority on Wednesday with more than half the precincts reporting.

San Francisco's mayor and top prosecutor spoke out Wednesday against the controversial ballot measure that would have decriminalized prostitution in the city, saying it would remove the ability of law enforcement to curb human trafficking and provide services for victims.

Speaking on a dingy street corner in the Tenderloin District, the site of a now-closed massage parlor, Mayor Gavin Newsom and District Attorney Kamala Harris pushed a message that prostitution is not a victimless crime.

"We can not give a green light or a pass to predators of young women," Harris said.

"This is so much bigger than what happens between consenting adults behind closed doors," she added.

Harris said prostitution often accompanies drug crime, violence and quality of life in neighborhoods such as the Tenderloin.

She said passage of Proposition K would not be "compassionate."

Newsom echoed Harris' comments.

"If Prop K passes, can you imagine living here?" he asked, motioning to the surrounding Tenderloin streets.

"This is serious business," he said. "We're trying to clean up the Tenderloin."

"If people really knew what was happening in these massage parlors, there would be outrage," Newsom said.

Supporters of the measure, who plan to hold their own news conference this afternoon, have said the legislation aims to increase safety for women and help sex workers report violence without fear of arrest.

The proposition calls on police to make sex workers' safety a priority by instead focusing on enforcing laws against assault, rape, kidnapping and extortion, supporters say.

They argue it would actually strengthen the prosecution of sex traffickers and protect immigrant women from arrest and deportation.

Comments (24)

Sort by: Most Recent | Oldest
  • BB Monday, Feb 16 at 1:09 AM FLAG COMMENT This is absolutely ridiculous. All you need to do is criminalize street prostitution, then set up brothels as being legal. In this legalized environment, these businesses would need to provide proof of legal age and proof of citizenship. They would also need to provide STD checks every month. -This would thereby get rid of ILLEGAL, FORCED prostitution and sex slavery, since city officials would be allowed to check up on th ... MORE >
  • NADINE Tuesday, Nov 18 at 6:24 PM FLAG COMMENT If you want to know what happens when you take away moral boundaries set to protect the most vulnerable members of society, i.e. our children, take a look at New Zealand news today, "Nia Glassie" is one more child victim of Government's changing our Christian foundation since 1984 and plummeting our kids into darkness, murdered and maimed in the most brutal ways imaginable. Teens and our most promising youth are going to jail ... MORE >
  • Emily Mackenzie Monday, Nov 10 at 6:52 AM FLAG COMMENT This is miraculous! Especially given what it must have taken in a town such as San Francisco, given its mostly liberal leanings. Now, if we could just continue the fight against other issues as well in other parts of the country.
  • Slava Friday, Nov 7 at 3:31 PM FLAG COMMENT Lucy, there is a huge difference between consenting to use your photo to advertise your sexual services and going to a press conference and having the media use a photo like this to represent you.
  • Sal Meier Friday, Nov 7 at 12:14 AM FLAG COMMENT In the Netherlands a measure like propostion K was adopted, but it did not lead to a decrease in violence against sex-workers. The industry stayed in the hands of criminals. The Dutch gorvernment is no trying to reverse its course.

Post a Comment

Name


Comment - You have 2000 characters left

Enter both words below, separated by a space, in the field located to the lower right. Can't read the words below? Try different words or an audio captcha. What's this?