Drake's Bay Oyster Farm Fights to Stay Open

The future of the company is now in the hands of three judges

View Comments ()
|
Email
|
Print

    NEWSLETTERS

    The owners of Drake s Bay Oyster Company on Tuesday asked a Federal Appeals Court to grant it an injunction to remain in business while the case plays out in court. Joe Rosato Jr. reports. (Published Tuesday, May 14, 2013)

    The owners of Drake’s Bay Oyster Company on Tuesday asked a Federal Appeals Court to grant it an injunction to remain in business while the case plays out in court.

    Attorneys for Cause of Action, the government watchdog group representing the oyster farm, appeared before a three-judge panel in the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals in San Francisco.

    Point Reyes Oyster Controversy

    [BAY] Point Reyes Oyster Controversy
    The National Park Service is set to decide this week whether or not to extend a lease for Kenny Lunny's Drake's Bay Oyster Farm. Environmentalists want the oyster company removed from the estuary. Joe Rosato Jr. reports. (Published Wednesday, Nov 28, 2012)

    The group is appealing then-Interior Secretary Ken Salazar’s decision in November to refuse to extend the oyster company’s lease on National Park land.

    The 9th circuit is reviewing a U.S. District court’s refusal to grant the oyster farm a preliminary injunction, halting the federal closure order. In the meantime, the oyster farm which employs 30 people continues to operate on a temporary emergency order.

    Feds To Shut Down Drake's Bay Oyster Farm

    [BAY] Feds To Shut Down Drake's Bay Oyster Farm
    The federal government will shut down an historic Northern California oyster farm along Point Reyes National Seashore, designating the site as a wilderness area. (Published Thursday, Nov 29, 2012)

    “We hope the decision will come down that we get the injunction,” said Kevin Lunny, co-owner of Drakes Bay Oyster Company. “We continue to plant our oysters and we continue to plant food for the San Francisco Bay Area."

    In court Tuesday, attorneys for Lunny laid out their case that Salazar relied on faulty scientific data in order to make his decision. But Federal judge Paul Watford questioned whether Congress had granted Salazar the power to make the decision at his own discretion.

    Life After Drake's Bay Oyster Company

    [BAY] Life After Drake's Bay Oyster Company
    Kevin Lunny's struggle to keep his family's oyster farm running in Point Reyes National Seashore appears to be over, closing out an era of oysterman plying the park's pristine waters and ushering in the nation's newest ocean wilderness. Joe Rosato Jr. reports. (Published Friday, Nov 30, 2012)

    “At the end of the day,” said Watford, “the secretary said the more important objective is to give effect essentially to Congress’ intent that this area be returned to wilderness status.”

    Attorneys for the Department of Justice, which is defending Salazar’s decision, echoed that the former interior secretary was within his right to end the farm’s lease.

    “His decision was based on the incompatibility of commercial activities in wilderness on a policy basis,” said government attorney David Gunter, “not on any disputed science.”

    The panel of judges didn’t immediately issue a ruling, and has no timetable for issuing its decision. Meanwhile, strange bedfellows have come to Lunny’s cause. Famed chef Alice Waters has filed a brief in support of the farm, and Republicans attached a proposal to extend the farm’s lease twenty years, to a proposed bill to open the Keystone Pipeline in Alaska.

    “We’re appreciative of anybody who be willing to stand up for what’s right,” responded Lunny. Environmental groups who have called for the oyster operation’s removal say the case could set a precedence for groups hoping to open National Park lands to commercial enterprises.

    “There are definitely special interests out there who are not looking out for the American people, “said Neal Desai of the National Parks Conservation Association, which supports the farm’s removal. If Lunny prevails at the federal appeals court, the case would return to the same Oakland U.S. District Court which denied the oyster farm’s initial request for an injunction.

    Standing out front of the federal court, dressed in a suit and tie, Lunny considered the long legal road ahead.

    “Our livelihood’s threatened right now by the fact that we may or may not be able to continue farming,” Lunny said.