Trump's Early Moves on Education Draw Concern, Praise - NBC Bay Area
National & International News
The day’s top national and international news

Trump's Early Moves on Education Draw Concern, Praise

Supporters of school choice say Trump is doing what's necessary

    processing...

    NEWSLETTERS

    Trump's Early Moves on Education Draw Concern, Praise
    Evan Vucci/AP
    File photo: President Donald Trump speaks in the Roosevelt Room of the White House in Washington, March 22, 2017.

    The nomination of Betsy DeVos, a school choice advocate, as Education secretary, was a signal from President Donald Trump that he was going to shake up public education.

    On Monday, Trump moved to roll back Obama-era rules that deal with how states assess school performance and teacher preparation programs. Trump says that local educators, parents and state leaders know what students need best.

    And his budget proposal brought even more clarity to his plan.

    But as the budget process begins to play out, education experts and teachers are wondering what the changes will mean. Will some children get left behind? Can schools already strapped for money survive even deeper cuts?

    Pence Breaks Tie, Confirms DeVos as Education Secretary

    [NATL] Pence Breaks Tie, Confirms DeVos as Education Secretary

    Mike Pence became the first vice president to break a tie for a cabinet hearing, confirming Betsy DeVos for education secretary despite objections from Democrat and some Republican senators.

    (Published Tuesday, Feb. 7, 2017)

    Education experts in favor of school choice and a shrinking role for the federal government in education sing the praises of the new administration. Critics, meanwhile, are worried about the future of education.

    Here is a closer look at the divide:  

    On Betsy DeVos and Donald Trump:

    Randi Weingarten, president of the American Federation of Teachers, called DeVos the most anti-public education person ever nominated, asserting she has an "antipathy toward anything that is public."

    "What you’re seeing from her is what happened in the hearing, which is both an ideological antipathy toward anything that is public, toward anything that’s... a public good, and a public concern, and public education," Weingarten said.

    DeVos is known for being a charter school and voucher program advocate, which has garnered her a great deal of criticism. But that doesn’t mean she’s lacking in support.

    Betsy DeVos Addresses Department of Education as Secretary

    [NATL] Betsy DeVos Addresses Department of  Education as Secretary

    Betsy DeVos addressed the Department of Education on Wednesday, Feb. 7, 2017, after a contentious confirmation vote saw the first tiebreaker from a vice president in history.   

    (Published Wednesday, Feb. 8, 2017)

    "[DeVos] is a passionate advocate for children," Robert Enlow, president and CEO of EdChoice, a pro-school choice group, said. "I think she supports schools of all types."

    He added that he believes she’s committed to making sure that low income families have the same opportunities as others.

    Lily Eskelsen Garcia, president of the National Education Association, the largest teacher’s union in the nation, has been a critic of DeVos from the start.

    "The only thing [DeVos] seems to want to talk about is how to funnel public dollars into private charter schools and private schools schools...we think that hurts students--to be supportive of taking public school dollars out of public schools and into unaccountable, privatized schools,” she said.

    She added that during the campaign, she felt that the only thing Trump talked about was school choice.

    "He didn’t mention education in any other form, except yes we need to fund privately managed schools somehow," she said.

    Trump, McConnell Discuss Legislative Priorities, GOP Unity

    [NATL] Trump Lays Out 'To-Do' List, Discusses Legislative Priorities With McConnell
    President Donald Trump and Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell stood together Monday as a show of solidarity during an impromptu question-and-answer session with reporters. 
    The two have publicly feuded in recent weeks, but now, as they're trying to advance the GOP agenda, they say they're closer than ever. 
    (Published Monday, Oct. 16, 2017)

    "Then he picked the poster child for how to do that in the worst way possible," Eskelsen added.

    On the budget:

    The administration this month proposed allocating an additional $1.4 billion for school choice programs and eliminating two programs worth $3.6 billion that provide funding for teacher preparation and after-school programs.

    Experts that spoke with NBC named a number of possibilities for the future of education throughout the next four years, but a common theme was tax credit scholarships, which "allow taxpayers to receive full or partial tax credits when they donate to nonprofits that provide private school scholarships," according to EdChoice.

    Jon Valant, a fellow in the Brown Center on Education Policy at the Brookings Institute, said he believes school choice is likely to be implemented through a tax credit school program.

    "Part of the reason they are likely to go that route is to get it through they could do it through the budget reconciliation process," he said.

    Trump Says Iran Deal Not in US National Security Interests

    [NATL] Trump Says Iran Deal Not in US National Security Interests

    "We will not continue down a path whose predictable conclusion is more violence, more terror and the very real threat of Iran's nuclear breakout," President Donald Trump said on Friday, Oct. 13, 2017.

    (Published Friday, Oct. 13, 2017)

    Enlow added that the administration can encourage--and that he would prefer--that families get more options through tax codes, which can be done in two ways: through scholarship tax credits and direct tax credits.

    "You should be funding every child," Enlow said.

    Rick Hess, resident scholar and director of Education Policy Studies at the American Enterprise Institute (AEI), also said tax credit scholarships are a possibility.

    "You’re talking something that would transform the private schooling sector," he said.

    Valant said the move is useful politically because it’s filibuster-proof.

    He added that there’s a real chance that such a program could change the way schools currently operate.

    Trump Signs Executive Order Re-Working Parts of Health Care

    [NATL] Trump Signs Executive Order Re-Working Parts of Health Care

    President Donald Trump signed an executive order Thursday, Oct. 12, 2017, seeking to expand insurance coverage across state lines through so-called association health plans. Those health plans will not exclude workers or charge more to those in poorer health, according to the White House.

    (Published Thursday, Oct. 12, 2017)

    If the government redirects a substantial amount of money to private schools, he said, then it’s likely that kids would take the scholarships to private schools.

    Valant said the program has the potential to take away funding from some places.

    "If they are redirecting a substantial amount of money to private schools then it would be very likely that we’d see kids taking those scholarships and taking them to private schools," he said.

    But while Trump’s budget has garnered some criticism, Enlow said, "I think it’s a good start."

    "Whether it stays that way or not, is of course up to Congress," he added.

    Weingarten criticized Trump’s new budget, which has substantial cuts in funding for education, and called it the perfect example of "ideological zeal" that she says blinded DeVos to what works in education.

    President Trump Gets Big Reaction After He Says 'Huge'

    [NATL] President Trump Gets Big Reaction After He Says 'Huge'

    President Trump received a big reaction after using one of his Trump-isms at a speech in Pennsylvania.

    (Published Wednesday, Oct. 11, 2017)

    "If you care about public education and you care about helping all kids and you care about what works in public schools, she’s not your champion," she said.

    On transgender bathroom laws:

    Garcia also pointed to the Trump administration’s rollback of federal guidelines on transgender bathroom usage in schools. The administration rolled back the Barack Obama’s administration’s guidelines that let students use bathrooms or locker rooms that aligned with their gender identities.

    Garcia said transgender kids are often misunderstood and victims, and she said they’re used as scapegoats. She said that in rolling back those guidelines, the Department of Ed is complicit in children’s suffering.

    "You will not get another chance to have children feel safe in their school once you have allowed them to feel unsafe," she said.

    When the guidance was lifted, DeVos said, "This is an issue best solved at the state and local level.”

    President Trump Summarizes His Tax Plan in Under a Minute

    [NATL] President Trump Summarizes His Tax Plan in Under a Minute

    President Donald Trump delivered a speech to lay out his tax plan on Oct. 11, 2017, in Pennsylvania.

    (Published Wednesday, Oct. 11, 2017)

    She added that schools, communities and families can find solutions that protect all students.

    On school choice:

    Recently, the text of a bill introduced by Rep. Steve King (R-IA) was going around social media, with many criticizing its tenets.

    H.R. 610, or the Choices in Education Act of 2017 moves to repeal the Elementary and Secondary Education Act (The law was recently reauthorized as the Every Student Succeeds Act, or ESSA), which provides funding to schools with low-income populations and homeless children, NBC 7 reported.

    The bill would also introduce a voucher system for schools using federal funds, and repeal nutrition standards that schools currently follow.

    Parents who receive vouchers through the proposed legislation would be able to make the ultimate decision on whether their child receives homeschooling, or attends public or private school.

    WH on Trump's Tillerson Comment: 'It Was a Joke'

    [NATL] White House on Trump's Tillerson Comment: 'It Was a Joke'

    White House press secretary Sarah Huckabee Sanders played down President Donald Trump's suggestion that he had a higher IQ than his Secretary of State, Rex Tillerson, calling it a joke. She also took shots at GOP lawmakers, saying "Congress has alienated themselves."  

    (Published Tuesday, Oct. 10, 2017)

    Such legislation would upend the current state of education in the United States, but according to experts it’s unlikely to pass.

    "What this particular act proposes would be revolutionary," said Kevin Welner, professor at the University of Colorado Boulder and director of the National Education Policy Center.

    Welner said the bill isn’t just a matter of tinkering with education--it’s a matter of completely eliminating the role of the Department of Education.

    "If this actually could happen it would be really, really troubling," Valant said of King’s bill. "But I don’t think it’s likely."

    ESSA was reauthorized in 2015, largely with bipartisan support--which is why experts say that they can’t see King’s bill passing.

    Valant also said that the bill is unlikely to garner much support among Democrats and Republicans.

    Corker: Trump on 'Path to WWIII'

    [NATL] Corker: Trump on 'Path to WWIII'

    President Donald Trump found himself in a drawn out feud with Sen. Bob Corker (R-Tenn.) after Corker criticized Trump's conduct in the White House in The New York Times. 

    (Published Tuesday, Oct. 10, 2017)

    "Even to do it with a simple majority would be tough," he said.

    For Republicans, Hess said, there’s a balancing act between wanting to dial back Washington’s involvement while also not wanting to look like they’re too hostile toward schools or school systems.

    "Even Democrats who are skeptical of testing don’t want Washington to get entirely out of this business," he said.

    Valant added that it’s too early to tell what tax credit scholarship programs could look like, but he said they wouldn’t be as stunningly revolutionary as the Choices in Education Act.

    "It would not disrupt the infrastructure of federal education policy like King’s proposal would, but it still has potential to have real consequences for kids and public schools," Valant said.

    On higher ed:

    Trump Jokes Penguins Co-Owner Should Help With NAFTA Negotiations

    [NATL] Trump Jokes Penguins Co-Owner Should Help With NAFTA Negotiations

    President Donald Trump on Tuesday jokingly asked Pittsburgh Penguins co-owner Ron Burkle if he would help re-negotiate NAFTA. The Penguins visited the White House to celebrate their Stanley Cup title.

    (Published Wednesday, Oct. 11, 2017)

    Weingarten named issues within higher education as some of the things she believes the department should be tackling, namely accountability.

    "We should be making private colleges accountable and not allow them to be predatory,” she said. "We should be increasing student loan opportunities not decreasing [them] to help kids who want to go to college, go to college."

    Hess said the Higher Education Act is "long overdue" for reauthorization.

    Trump Warns of 'Calm Before the Storm'

    [NATL] Trump Warns of 'Calm Before the Storm'

    President Donald Trump’s cryptic comment as he posed for pictures with top military leaders Thursday is drawing scrutiny.

    "You guys know what this represents, maybe it's the calm before the storm," Trump told reporters as he posed for photos with senior military leaders.

    Trump didn't clarify the remark, which some speculated could refer to either action against North Korea's nuclear weapons program or a withdrawal from the Iran nuclear pact.

    (Published Friday, Oct. 6, 2017)

    "There’s a real opportunity to take a look at the way we fund student loans...and support colleges to ensure that institutions are being encouraged to think about cost effectiveness and about the quality of education they’re providing" he said.

    This article contains material from the Associated Press