Arizona's New Immigration Law

Protecting the State or Creating a Police State?

Monday, May 10, 2010  |  Updated 11:31 AM PDT
View Comments (
<a title=Suzanne Shaw, NBC Bay Area Editorial Director looks at Arizona's polarizing new immigration law" />

Suzanne Shaw, NBC Bay Area Editorial Director looks at Arizona's polarizing new immigration law

Photos and Videos

Arizona's New Immigration Law: Your Viewer Responses

Is Arizona's new immigration law setting a dangerous precedent? Suzanne Shaw highlights your viewer feedback
More Photos and Videos

And now, an NBC Bay Area Editorial...

Arizona's new immigration law is a knee-jerk reaction to Washington's in-action.

I'm Suzanne Shaw, NBC Bay Area Editorial Director.

Making police demand papers from anyone who looks undocumented promotes racial profiling and harassment!

Arizona's exiles will flood California.

Boycotts by San Francisco and others will backfire.

And we'll create a bigger black market for counterfeit documents.

These moves do nothing to solve our national immigration problem. Congress has wasted years debating and Arizonans are frustrated.

But how can we say, "all men are created equal" except for the ones without papers? Our nation was built on the backs of immigrants.

We need national immigration reform. We need the taxes workers should be paying for education and health care.

Immigrants aren't going away. They'll just go deeper underground.


Please scroll down to view the comments or leave your own.  Please include your first name, the first inital of your last name and your city, or you can post anonymously.

Get the latest headlines sent to your inbox!
View Comments (
Leave Comments
Bay Area Proud
Bay Area Proud is NBC Bay... Read more
Follow Us
Sign up to receive news and updates that matter to you.
Send Us Your Story Tips
Check Out