ACLU Questions SJ Man Arrested in Bomb Plot - NBC Bay Area

ACLU Questions SJ Man Arrested in Bomb Plot

A civil rights group says the plot smells like entrapment



    Matthew Llaneza of San Jose was arrested Friday by the FBI in an alleged would-be bomb plot. The ACLU is critical of these FBI terrorist sting operations where undercover agents help create the plot themselves. Terry McSweeney reports. (Published Wednesday, Feb. 13, 2013)

    Some civil rights groups are questioning the tactics of a mentally ill San Jose man arrested on Friday in alleged bomb plot of an Oakland bank.

    Matthew Llaneza, 28, returns to federal court Thursday  for a bail hearing after the FBI took him into custody on Friday in a monthslong undercover sting where he was handed fake bomb making materials and arrested outside the Bank of America on Hegenberger Road as he was allegedly poised to set the device off. According to court records, Llaneza suffers from mental illness, is paranoid and is a Muslim convert who became a "jidhadist."

    His federal public defender has declined comment.

    Mike German, an attorney with the American Civil Liberties Union in San Francisco told NBC Bay Area on Tuesday that it doesn't feel right when an agency suggests a plot and then helps see it through. He said it feels more like a "theatrical prodcuction."

    FBI Sting Thwarts Oakland Terror Attack Attempt

    [BAY] FBI Sting Thwarts Oakland Terror Attack Attempt
    A California man who thought he was meeting someone linked to the Taliban was arrested Friday morning after federal agents say he tried to detonate some sort of car-bomb at a Bank of America branch near Oakland's airport.
    (Published Friday, Feb. 8, 2013)

    His comments echo what, Zahra Billoo, executive director of the Council on American Islamic Relations in Santa Clara, has previously said.

     "Did the FBI take a [mentally ill] aspirational terrorist, make him an operational terrorist and then thwart their own plot?" Billoo asked. "CAIR has been saying this for years now: It's the FBI's job to stop operational terrorists. It's not the FBI's job to enable aspirational ones."

    The FBI documents provided no evidence that Llaneza could have pulled off the operation without the undercover agents, had ties to other terrorists or had any bomb making materials in his possession.

    FBI Expert Terror Says Catch Saved Lives

    [BAY] FBI Expert Terror Says Catch Saved Lives
    LaRae Quy, a former FBI counterintelligence and undercover agent, said the FBI's ability to gain Llaneza's trust likely saved lives. "The undercover agent was able to establish a rapport and real trust so this individual was able to feel comfortable with trusting him with this bigger plan, and even involved him in it."
    (Published Friday, Feb. 8, 2013)


    But according to the FBI affadavits, Llaneza was ready and willing to engage ina civil war against America.

    Alleged Terrorist Had History of Mental Illness

    [BAY] Alleged Terrorist Had History of Mental Illness
    The NBC Bay Area has learned a great deal about 28-year-old Matthew Llaneza through court records and a variety of sources.Llaneza served in the Marines, but not his full term. Sources say he was discharged for medical reasons. Tony Kovaleski investigates.
    (Published Friday, Feb. 8, 2013)

    According to the federal affidavit, Llaneza met with a man on Nov. 30 who led him to believe he was connected with the Taliban and the mujahidin in Afghanistan. The man was really an undercover FBI agent.


    At the meeting, Llaneza proposed conducting a car-bomb attack against a bank in the San Francisco Bay Area, the complaint alleges. He proposed structuring the attack to make it appear that the responsible party was an umbrella organization for a loose collection of anti-government militias and their sympathizers, according to prosecutors.

    Llaneza’s stated goal was to trigger a governmental crackdown, prosecutors said, which he expected would trigger a right-wing counter-response against the government followed by, he hoped, civil war.

    Llaneza identified the Federal Reserve Bank in San Francisco as a good target, the affadavit states, or a local bank as good targets for the attack.

    After figuring the Federal Reserve would have "too much security," on Dec. 7, Llaneza ended up choosing the Bank of America branch at 303 Hegenberger Road in Oakland as the target for the attack, the complaint states. That bank is near the city's airport.

    A week later, Llaneza found a spot next to a support column of the bank building as a good location for the bomb, expressed a desire for the bomb to bring down the entire bank building, and offered to drive the car bomb to the bank at the time of the attack, prosecutors alleged in a statement.

    According to the complaint, in January and February, Llaneza and the undercover agent constructed the fake explosive device inside an SUV parked inside a storage facility in Hayward.

    As part of the process of assembling the device, Llaneza allegedly bought two cell phones to be used in creating and operating the trigger device for the car bomb. One of these cell phones was incorporated into the trigger device itself. The other was reserved for use on the night of the attack.

    The criminal complaint alleges that on Thursday evening, Llaneza drove the SUV containing the purported explosive device to the target bank branch in Oakland.

    He parked the SUV beneath an overhang of the bank building where he armed the trigger device, according to the complaint.

    He then allegedly proceeded on foot to a nearby location a safe distance from the bank building, where he met the undercover agent. Once there, prosecutors Llaneza allegedly attempted to detonate the bomb by using the second cell phone he had purchased to place two calls to the trigger device attached to the car bomb, according to prosecutors.

    That's when the FBI placed him under arrest.

    German, from the ACLU, doesn't know if Llaneza is guilty or not. But he did say that when the FBI helps set up a crime, there is usually "far more damage that they ever could have done on their own."