The popular home-sharing company Airbnb is suing San Francisco in order to block an upcoming change in law that could potentially put the online-based company, and other websites like it, on the hook for thousands of dollars in fines per day.
Earlier this month, the San Francisco Board of Supervisors took steps to begin holding home-sharing companies, including Airbnb, accountable for any illegal short-term rentals they post on their websites. The change in law is scheduled to take effect in July and would require home-sharing websites to verify that listings are registered with the city before posting them online. Otherwise, companies could face government issued penalties of up to $1,000 per day.
In an 18-page lawsuit filed on Monday, Airbnb argued the law infringes on its first amendment rights of commercial speech.
“Instead of punishing Airbnb for publishing unlawful listings, the City could enforce its short-term rental law directly against hosts who violate it,” the lawsuit said. “The ordinance imposes a significant burden on Airbnb to verify the registration numbers associated with each of the thousands of San Francisco rental listings on its platform.”
Beginning in February 2015, anyone wanting to rent out their San Francisco home for less than 30 days has been required to register with the city and remain the primary resident of that home. In May, however, the Investigative Unit found that thousands of short-term rental hosts across the city continue to break the law.
Airbnb has told the Investigative Unit it has cracked down on illegal posts, and recently launched a new feature on its site allowing neighbors to report problems directly to the company. Airbnb, however, has said implementing the city’s new requirements would be far too problematic.
“To comply with the Ordinance, Airbnb would need to remove a substantial number of listings from its site, including listings that otherwise comply with San Francisco law,” the lawsuit stated. “Removing these listings would cause a substantial disruption to Airbnb’s business and have a significant detrimental effect on Airbnb’s goodwill and reputation among both hosts and guests, thus threatening irreparable injury to Airbnb’s business.”
Critics of the law, including Airbnb, argue the city’s registration process for hosts remains far too complicated. Supporters of the measure, however, believe the added restrictions would help put more housing stock back on the market for full-time residents.
“We believe we are on firm legal footing with this case because this is a piece of common sense legislation that is supported by landlords, tenants, hotels, and hotel workers,” said Supervisor Aaron Peskin, who authored the legislation. “We are confident that our City Attorney will successfully present our case.”
A spokesperson for the city attorney’s office said San Francisco intends to defend the law in court, saying home-sharing companies need to be responsible for who they allow to use their online platform.
“It's simply a duty to verify information that's already required of a regulated business activity,” said Matt Dorsey, Press Secretary for the City Attorney’s Office.” In the same way alcohol and cigarette vendors are required to verify the ages of their customers, Dorsey says home-sharing companies should be required to verify the information of their users.
“Businesses that sell those products have a legal duty to verify the age of their customers, whether it's online or at the corner store, so they don't sell alcohol and cigarettes to children,” Dorsey said. “It’s the same principal.”
Need to contact our Investigative Unit?
• You can remain anonymous
Watch the entire series in this NBC Bay Area investigation:
- Part 1: Thousands Violate SF Housing Laws Using Airbnb, Few Face Penalties
- Part 2: Illegal Short-Term Rentals Can be Nightmare for Neighbors
- Part 3: San Francisco Lawmakers Could Soon Force Airbnb, Other Home-Sharing Websites to Make Major Changes
- Part 4: Airbnb Sues SF to Block New Law Aimed at Delisting "Illegal Rentals"
- Part 5: SF Law Targeting "Illegal Rentals" on Hold as City Battles Airbnb Lawsuit
- Part 6: Airbnb Heads to Federal Court Over Lawsuit Against San Francisco
- Part 7: Judge Raises Doubts Over Airbnb's Lawsuit Against San Francisco
- Part 8: Judge Orders SF to Hold Off on Airbnb Fines and Penalties
- Part 9: Airbnb and SF Meet Privately to Settle Bitter Lawsuit
- Part 10: San Francisco Limits How Often Hosts Can Use Airbnb
- Part 11: Airbnb's New Rules Abroad Could Impact San Francisco
- Part 12: SF Issues $1.1 Million in Fines to Hosts Using Rental Sites Like Airbnb
- Part 13: Thousands of Airbnb Rental Listings in SF Could Soon Be Purged