Judging by Algorithm: Using Risk Factors to Score Defendants - NBC Bay Area
National & International News
The day’s top national and international news

Judging by Algorithm: Using Risk Factors to Score Defendants

Supporters of such assessments say they limit prejudicial judgments, while critics say they can turn judging into a rote exercise — one that might perpetuate hidden biases within the criminal justice system

    Winter Olympics PyeongChang 2018 Medal Count
    Country
    Total
    1
    Norway
    78722
    2
    Germany
    94417
    3
    Canada
    55515
    processing...

    NEWSLETTERS

    10 Snow Sports Moments That Changed The Olympics Forever
    AP Photo/Dario Lopez-Mills, File
    In this July 12, 2008, file photo, a gavel rests on the table of a model courtroom at Mexico's National Institute of Penal Sciences in Mexico City.

    Instead of holding criminal defendants on cash bail, courts around the United States are increasingly using algorithmic risk-assessment tools to help judges decide if a defendant should be jailed or go free while awaiting trial.

    One such model now used by New Jersey and other state and regional courts is the Public Safety Assessment, developed by the Houston-based Laura and John Arnold Foundation.

    Supporters of such assessments say they limit prejudicial judgments, while critics say they can turn judging into a rote exercise — one that might perpetuate hidden biases within the criminal justice system.

    The Arnold Foundation's model uses these nine risk factors to evaluate a defendant, including age and past criminal convictions. (It excludes race, gender, employment history and where a person lives.) These are:

    1. Age at current offense

    2. Current violent offense

    3. Pending charge at the time of the offense

    4. Prior misdemeanor conviction

    5. Prior felony conviction

    6. Prior violent conviction

    Russians Indicted for Alleged Election Meddling Conspiracy

    [NATL] Russians Indicted for Alleged Election Meddling Conspiracy

    Deputy Attorney General Rod Rosenstein announces indictments against 13 Russians and three Russian entities accused of meddling in the 2016 U.S. presidential election.

    (Published Friday, Feb. 16, 2018)

    7. Prior failure to appear to a court hearing in the past two years

    8. Prior failure to appear older than two years

    9. Prior sentence to incarceration