Judge Refuses to Block Trump Bank Subpoenas - NBC Bay Area
National & International News
The day’s top national and international news

Judge Refuses to Block Trump Bank Subpoenas

Deutsche Bank has lent Trump's real estate company millions of dollars over the years

    processing...

    NEWSLETTERS

    Judge Refuses to Block Trump Bank Subpoenas
    Evan Vucci/AP
    President Donald Trump speaks during a campaign rally, Monday, May 20, 2019, in Montoursville, Pa.

    A New York judge refused Wednesday to block congressional subpoenas seeking financial records from two banks that did business with President Donald Trump, making it clear it wasn't a close call.

    U.S. District Judge Edgardo Ramos said in a ruling delivered from the bench that Trump and his company were "highly unlikely" to succeed in a lawsuit arguing that the subpoenas seeking records from Deutsche Bank and Capital One were unlawful and unconstitutional.

    Ramos also concluded that the subpoenas have "a legitimate legislative purpose" and dismissed one-by-one arguments made to try to bury them, though he conceded that records released publicly could cause Trump and his family irreparable harm.

    The lawyers for the House Financial Services and Intelligence committees say they need access to documents from the banks to investigate possible "foreign influence in the U.S. political process" and possible money laundering from abroad.

    Hong Kong Leader Says No Compromise as Violence Escalates

    [NATL] Hong Kong Leader Says No Compromise as Protest Violence Escalates

    Hong Kong’s government is refusing to compromise after one pro-democracy protester was shot and another set on fire in a rare weekday protest. The five-month protest has seen a steady rise in violence, with both pro-democracy protesters and the Hong Kong government refusing to give ground.

    (Published Monday, Nov. 11, 2019)

    Deutsche Bank has lent Trump's real estate company millions of dollars over the years.

    When Ramos finished reading aloud a lengthy ruling, he asked Trump's lawyer, Patrick Strawbridge, if he would appeal.

    "That's probably a safe bet," Strawbridge responded.

    The judge then noted that both sides had agreed that the subpoenas would not require a response for another week, giving Trump, his family and his companies time to appeal.

    The hearing falls two days after a federal judge in Washington ruled against Trump in a similar case, finding that the president cannot block a House subpoena for information from a financial services firm that had done accounting work for him and the Trump Organization.

    And it comes a day after Trump blocked his former White House lawyer, Don McGahn, from testifying before the House Judiciary Committee.

    First Transcripts in Impeachment Inquiry Released

    [NATL] Impeachment Inquiry: Yovanovitch, McKingly Transcripts Released

    House Democrats on Monday released the written record of testimony from two witnesses who say they were caught up in the Trump administration's efforts to pressure Ukraine to investigate the president's political rivals. Those witnesses: former top State Department official Michael McKinley and former U.S. Ambassador to Ukraine Marie Yovanovitch. NBC's Alice Barr reports.

    (Published Tuesday, Nov. 5, 2019)

    In a written submission prior to Wednesday's hearing, lawyers for two congressional committees wrote that Trump's effort to block the subpoenas was "flatly inconsistent with nearly a century of Supreme Court precedent."

    Attorney Douglas Letter cited some of those rulings when he argued before Ramos on Wednesday that Trump should not be able to block "a very major complex investigation across a whole industry, not just Mr. Trump."

    He said there were about 10 subpoenas sent to individuals or entities that have "nothing to do with Mr. Trump."

    Letter said there is a "massive fundamental misunderstanding by Mr. Trump about Congress ... that we're a nuisance and we can't investigate him."

    In court papers, lawyers said the House's Committee on Financial Services and Permanent Select Committee on Intelligence sought the information as they investigate "serious and urgent questions concerning the safety of banking practices, money laundering in the financial sector, foreign influence in the U.S. political process, and the threat of foreign financial leverage, including over the president, his family and his business."

    Lawyers for Trump responded in writing that accepting the view of the committees would mean "Congress can issue a subpoena on any matter, at any time, for any reason, to any person, and there is basically nothing a federal court can do about it."

    Roger Stone Trial Begins

    [NATL] Roger Stone Trial Begins

    Roger Stone’s trial begins as he walked into federal court this Tuesday morning. Stone is accused of lying to congress and pressuring another person to lie as well.

    (Published Tuesday, Nov. 5, 2019)

    Trump's lawyers had asked the judge to temporarily block Congress from obtaining the records.

    The banks took no position in the dispute.

    The ruling is the second blow in New York on Wednesday to the privacy of Trump's financial details. State lawmakers earlier passed a measure that would allow the president's tax returns to be released to congressional committees.