City Budget

City Council Approves Budget With $27M More for San Diego Police After Hundreds Call to Defund

"We did not defund the San Diego Police Department because, to help restore trust in our police department, we need to focus more on neighborhood policing," Council President Pro Tem Barbara Bry's statement said, in part

NBCUniversal, Inc.

The San Diego City Council has voted 8-1 to adopt the proposed budget for the 2021 fiscal year, which includes the creation of a city Office of Race and Equity to tackle racial equity issues and a $27 million boost for the San Diego Police Department.

The vote came late Monday night following more than 10 hours of public comments from callers, many of whom called for a reduction in police department funding.

Councilmember Chris Ward cast the only dissenting vote, saying on Twitter, "We need to allocate more funding into rental assistance, small business assistance, we need to put federal dollars to use for the people who need it. I don't think we've gone far enough."

The council approved the budget late Monday night after hours of public comment.

Mayor Kevin Faulconer said he will sign the approved budget for the fiscal year, which begins July 1.

Following another weekend of largely peaceful protests against police brutality, the council heard public comments -- both written and telephoned in -- from hundreds of residents urging the council to reject a proposed $27 million increase in the budget for the San Diego Police Department.

Mayor Kevin Faulconer's proposed budget would increase the police budget to $566 million for the fiscal year 2021, constituting about a third of the city's general fund budget. The previous year's budget for the SDPD was $539 million and 2019's was $480 million.

The majority of callers asked for the police to be defunded, with funds going toward marginalized and vulnerable communities instead. Speakers asked for the money to be used for homeless outreach, mental health services, racial equity commissions and rent-assistance programs, among myriad other ideas.

Council President Pro Tem Barbara Bry said she was overall pleased with the proposal and said the choice to increase SDPD funding made to "help restore trust."

"We did not defund the San Diego Police Department because, to help restore trust in our police department, we need to focus more on neighborhood policing which means recruiting more officers committed to this approach, providing them with better training and support, and strengthening community oversight," she said in a written statement following the meeting. "That is why I continue to support the ballot measure for a community-led independent police review board with subpoena power.  As Chair of the Budget Committee, I will request regular expenditure updates, and I am asking that the Council host public discussion about implementation of the Campaign Zero policies."

Councilwoman Monica Montgomery proposed the creation of the Office of Race and Equity to address some of the concerns the citizens voiced with policing.

"As elected officials, we must honestly and genuinely address the root causes of the local protests -- the inequity in enforcement and the systemic racism that is prevalent in our region," she said. "From the beginning of my administration, I have championed a holistic approach to reform measures, including economic justice components. This new Office on Race and Equity is another step in the right direction, along with other reform measures."

For several hours, the number of callers waiting to speak to the council exceeded the phone line's capacity, with many having to wait before they could even call in to wait in a queue to speak. At 1 p.m., the city's phone system crashed and the council took a break to get it running again.

Matthew Bishop, a licensed marriage and family therapist and former Associate Director at the San Diego Rescue Mission, called in to describe the way he said he's seen law enforcement treat homeless people.

"It's embarrassing with a capital E," he said. "There's an old saying that if all you have are hammers, everything starts to look like a nail. If you give more resources to the hammers of our city -- the police -- more and more people are going to look like nails."

Bishop who works in Bankers Hill said he wants city council to allocate funds towards affordable housing and after school care programs. He also wants to see mental health and social workers called to help de-escalate situations.

"We have cops, but lets also have therapists, social workers people who are trained to de-escalate situations, we don't need to send a cop out to a dispute with their neighbor," explained Bishop.

Andrew Baker, a Golden Hill resident called in asking the council reject the budget, he wants to see funds go towards other programs and efforts that tailor and serve the community.

Lauren Rose, a San Diego resident from District 4, said the thought of more public funding going toward the police department "makes me sick."

The in-custody death of George Floyd in Minneapolis and the no-knock raid and shooting death of Breonna Taylor in Louisville have sparked an unprecedented public call for defunding of police nationwide. Los Angeles Mayor Eric Garcetti announced he would cut that city's police funding by $150 million and the majority of the Minneapolis City Council vowed to dismantle the city's police department.

Monique Rosas, a District 6 resident, echoed many speakers when she asked that the San Diego police budget be decreased by $100 million, including $42.2 million in Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security Act funding which Faulconer had allocated for the department.

She and many other speakers mentioned the names of people killed by law enforcement in the San Diego region over the last several years, including James Lacy, who was shot by two sheriff's deputies in 2017. Multiple people also referenced an incident last week when a 59-year-old grandmother was hit with a "non-lethal" beanbag round reportedly fired by a La Mesa police officer during a protest in that city, leaving her in a medically-induced coma that she has since awoken from.

Aleah Jenkins, who died after falling unconscious while in SDPD custody in 2018, was also on the minds of several callers.

A more recent incident on Thursday, in which plainclothes detectives arrested a woman and took her away in an unmarked van after a protest march downtown, was also the subject of several callers' concerns with the department's practices.

An internal investigation has been ordered by San Diego Police Chief David Nisleit into the controversial arrest by San Diego police detectives.

Police say undercover officers watched the woman swing a cardboard sign at a
passing motorcycle officer, then arrested her and loaded her into the van for safety reasons because of the surrounding crowd. She was booked into jail on
suspicion of assault on a peace officer.

Other public comments questioned the increase of police funding using COVID-19 relief funds during a time when people were suffering.

"Millions of people are losing their jobs and you're funding the police?'' said Huy Tran, a local political activist who said he was appalled by the "immoral" budget proposal.

The approved budget includes $15.1 million dollars to rental-relief efforts that have impacted those who lost their jobs to the COVID-19 pandemic.

"We must not allow this public-health emergency to push our struggling residents into homelessness, further reinforcing inequities," said Council President Georgette Gómez.

Contact Us