ORLANDO - The baseball world spent the month of November waiting for Giancarlo Stanton to narrow his list and find a new home. It turns out the finalists were decided on the field in October.
Stanton's agent, Joel Wolfe, confirmed Monday that the National League MVP preferred to play for the Yankees, Astros, Cubs or Dodgers. On the first day of the annual Winter Meetings, Stanton donned the pinstripes for the first time, and he talked about why he felt New York was the right fit in the end. He also talked about why he bothered meeting with the Giants and Cardinals if they were not on his original wish list.
"(The Marlins) went to San Francisco and the Cardinals and struck deals with them," Stanton said during a press conference. "So I was open to listening to them, but those were not my teams. Those are great people. They were great meetings and a great organization and culture there, but that just wasn't the fit for me."
The Giants flew their executives down to Los Angeles to meet with Stanton and his representatives and they felt the meeting went well. They had already agreed to terms on a package with the Marlins, with mid-level prospects being sent over in return. They were ready to assume the vast majority of the $295 million left on Stanton's deal.
But this process was controlled by the player, and Stanton called the Marlins' bluff. He said repeatedly on Monday that he wants to win and he's tired of rebuilding, and he forced his way to a team that looks ready to kickstart another lengthy run of October appearances.
The Giants and Cardinals have been postseason mainstays over the past decade, and surely that intrigued Stanton a bit, even if he had other plans. He said he wanted to learn what both organizations were about and that was part of the meeting process.
"All I've experienced is the Marlins and basically one way of going about things," he said. "So I wanted to see how other organizations went about their business and how the city and everything would appeal to me if that was a way that I wanted to go."
During an appearance on MLB Network after his press conference, Stanton said he hopes Giants and Cardinals fans don't hold the process against him. For the Giants, at the very least, Stanton is not a Dodger, and that played a part in this process, too. Wolfe compared Stanton - a Los Angeles native - to Brandon Crawford (another of his clients) potentially playing for the Dodgers. When he met with a scrum of reporters, Stanton said playing for his childhood team's rival played a small part in the process.
"I wouldn't base a decision off that but also I wouldn't want to go to the team that (the Dodgers) dislike the most, and I wasn't sure if (the Giants) were going to beat that team, either," Stanton said. "But at the same time if they were in the right position that I wanted, I would have done it."