Jurors to Keep Deliberating in Bryan Stow Beating Case

The group couldn't reach a consensus on the first question on the jury form

View Comments (
)
|
Email
|
Print

    NEWSLETTERS

    Jurors of the Bryan Stow trial are deadlocked on one question: were or weren't the Dodgers negligent? Gordon Tokumatsu reports from LA Superior Court for the NBC4 News at 5 p.m. on Wednesday, July, 2, 2014. (Published Wednesday, Jul 2, 2014)

    Jurors told a judge Wednesday they were deadlocked in a negligence lawsuit filed by a San Francisco Giants fan who suffered severe brain damage in a beating at Dodger Stadium.

    The judge, however, told them to keep deliberating.

    The 12-member Los Angeles County Superior Court panel began deliberations on June 26 in the case by Bryan Stow but said it was unable to reach a consensus of at least nine jurors on the question of whether there was negligence by the Dodgers or former owner Frank McCourt.

    It's the first question on the complex jury verdict form.

    Judge Victor E. Chavez told jurors that they must answer the questions in order and sent them back to work. They deliberated for about an hour before going home for the day. The panel will return to court Thursday.

    Stow, a 45-year-old former paramedic from Northern California, was attacked by two Dodger fans as he and friends walked through a parking lot after the 2011 opening game between the Dodgers and San Francisco Giants.

    He was knocked down from behind, hit his head on the pavement and then was kicked in the head.

    Dodger fans Louie Sanchez and Marvin Norwood pleaded guilty in the attack after a lengthy preliminary hearing in which witnesses said security guards were not seen in the parking lot where Stow was attacked.

    Medical experts testified that Stow will never work again and has suffered repeated strokes and seizures. They said he will always require around the clock care.

    Noted personal injury lawyer Tom Girardi filed the lawsuit on behalf of Stow, seeking $37.5 million for his lifetime care and compensation for lost earnings. He also urged jurors to award double that figure for pain and suffering.

    Dana Fox, the lawyer for the Dodgers and McCourt, argued that security was stronger than ever at an opening day contest and that the team and McCourt bore no responsibility for the attack.

    In closing arguments, he showed jurors enlarged photos of Sanchez and Norwood and said they were responsible along with Stow himself.

    Fox cited testimony that Stow's blood-alcohol level was .18 percent — more than twice the legal limit for driving — and a witness account of Stow yelling in the parking lot with his arms up in the air.