Test Invest – Still No Answer for $650 Million Question

No calculations provided for where $650 million came from.

It’s the 650 million dollar question that remains unanswered.

Last month we reported San Jose City Council members asked to see the math behind the five-year retirement cost projection of $650 million used by Mayor Chuck Reed in this memo

Last month, the City Manager said they would get answers today during a study session, as we reported.

This comes after our exclusive investigation in which Retirement Services Director, Russell Crosby, told us the number was off the top of his head.

However, no answers were given.

Instead, Debra Figone issued this memo, dated last week.

It says the number was an estimate, but doesn't say how it was estimated.

The Investigative Unit

Have a tip for The Investigative Unit? Call 1-888-996-TIPS.

A look at air quality monitors in the Bay Area

Oakland still hasn't installed 911 technology it bought 5 years ago


Most of the study session was spent talking about the latest retirement cost projection of $320 million and looking at pessimistic scenarios and how their occurrence could affect pension projections.

District 2 Councilman Ash Karla spoke with us after the meeting and said,  the memo explaining the $650 million projection has only raised more questions.

"I don’t think the memo directly answered the questions," Kalra said, "it  gave the overall sentiment that these numbers were off the top of his head and the staff encourages that kind of dialog and I encourage that type of dialog too, but when numbers taken from that dialog are used so publicly we need to know how much we can rely on those numbers."
Kalra also said the public use of the estimate, makes it important to know their derivation.
"In this case it doesn’t seem those numbers should have been relied upon, but they were relied upon very publicly. So why was no one told they shouldn’t haven’t been replied upon?" 
City Manager Debra Figone was not present at the meeting.
Deputy City Manager Alex Gurza told us he did not have time to talk with us today.
Do you have something you want us to look into?

Call our tip line: 1-888-996-TIPS

Contact Us