- Bed Bath & Beyond jumped after GameStop Chairman Ryan Cohen revealed he had a nearly 10% stake in the retailer, through his investment company RC Ventures.
- Cohen, who also co-founded online pet retailer Chewy, wrote in a letter to Bed Bath's board that he believes the retailer is struggling to reverse market share losses and to navigate supply chain woes.
- He said the company should explore selling itself to private equity and spinning off its Buybuy Baby chain.
- "We will carefully review their letter and hope to engage constructively around the ideas they have put forth," Bed Bath said in a statement.
Cohen, who also co-founded online pet retailer Chewy, wrote in a letter to Bed Bath's board that he believes the retailer is struggling to reverse market share losses and to navigate supply chain woes. He also criticized top executives, including Bed Bath Chief Executive Mark Tritton, for reaping excessive compensation during periods of underperformance.
Get a weekly recap of the latest San Francisco Bay Area housing news. Sign up for NBC Bay Area’s Housing Deconstructed newsletter.
"We believe Bed Bath needs to narrow its focus to fortify operations and maintain the right inventory mix to meet demand, while simultaneously exploring strategic alternatives that include separating Buybuy Baby, and a full sale of the company," said Cohen.
In response to the letter, which Bed Bath said it received Sunday evening, the big-box retailer said that it has had no prior contact with RC Ventures.
"We will carefully review their letter and hope to engage constructively around the ideas they have put forth," Bed Bath said in a statement. "2021 marked the first year of execution of our bold, multi-year transformation plan, which we believe will create significant long-term shareholder value."
Cohen's push for changes at Bed Bath comes after the retailer in 2019 settled a monthslong spat with a trio of activist investors in which four new members where added to its board. At the time, the activist group criticized Bed Bath's e-commerce presence relative to peers including Amazon.
Soon after that settlement was reached, the retailer brought on Tritton, a former Target executive, as CEO. His appointment sparked hope among investors that a turnaround was in the works, given Tritton's deep merchandising experience and success at Target.
Since taking the helm of the company, Tritton has embarked on closing hundreds of underperforming Bed Bath locations, selling noncore assets including Cost Plus World Market and Christmas Tree Shops, ramping up stock buybacks, remodeling stores, debuting numerous private labels, and more recently navigating Bed Bath through a pandemic.
Cohen, however, said Bed Bath's "scattershot strategy" isn't working. He said the company could be better suited with a private equity owner, and he also contends that the company's Buybuy Baby chain could be worth several billion dollars.
With a nearly 10% stake in Bed Bath, that makes Cohen a top five shareholder in the retailer, which had a market value of roughly $1.6 billion as of Friday's market close. Bed Bath shares have dropped nearly 45% in the last 12 months.
Telsey Advisory Group analyst Cristina Fernandez said in a note to clients that Bed Bath needs to improve operations and its inventory mix, two issues that the retailer had prior to the pandemic. Bed Bath also needs to speed delivery of online orders, as it lags competitors, she said.
However, according to Fernandez, a sale of the entire company is less certain as there have been opportunities for private equity to purchase it in the past and no suitors emerged. Cohen also pushed for a sale at GameStop, which did not happen, she noted.
Wells Fargo analyst Zachary Fadem, sharing a similar feeling that there is work left to do at Bed Bath, said that the company has weakening fundamentals and is "structurally disadvantaged."
"Considering Bed Bath's 26% short interest and low investor expectations for improving results, today's likely move higher is understandable," he wrote in a note to clients.
Cohen said in his letter that given his focus on GameStop, he isn't in a position to become a Bed Bath director himself. But he said this doesn't prevent him from holding the board and management accountable.
Cohen joined GameStop's board in January 2021, contributing to a Reddit-fueled surge in the video game retailer's shares, and took over as chairman in June of that year. He co-founded Chewy in 2011 and served as its CEO through 2018.