Matthew Muller, Vallejo Kidnap Suspect, Pleads No Contest in Dublin Home Invasion - NBC Bay Area
East Bay

East Bay

The latest news from around the East Bay

Matthew Muller, Vallejo Kidnap Suspect, Pleads No Contest in Dublin Home Invasion

Muller's battles with mental illness will likely be a part of the defense's strategy, his lawyer said.



    Not Getting Enough Sleep? What’s Your Excuse?
    Alameda County Sheriff
    Matthew Muller

    The suspect at the center of a kidnap case out of Vallejo, Calif. entered a no contest plea on Friday in a separate matter stemming from a Dublin home invasion.

    The Alameda County Superior Court hearing in Hayward was delayed for a short while as Matthew Muller felt woozy, started sweating profusely and sat down.

    But his attorney Tom Johnson said he ended up pleading no contest, essentially a guilty plea, to four counts of battery, robbery and assault. Johsnson said that Muller suffers from mental illness. He could face a maximum of 11 years in prison for a June break-in at a home on Terracina Avenue when police say he tried to tie up a homeowner and his wife with zip ties.

    "He became faint and sat down," Johnson told reporters and photographers outside in the hallway as cameras were not allowed in the courtroom of Judge Joseph Hurley. "It's unfortunate that he became faint. Court is stressful. But he recovered quickly."

    Attorney Tom Johnson speaks to reporters at the Alameda County Superior Courthouse after Matthew Muller pleads no contest in a Dublin home invasion case. Friday, Sept. 18, 2015
    Photo credit: Alan Waples

    Johnson added that Muller is "pleased it's over," and while he wouldn't explain why he plead no contest, he told reporters that everything his client is doing is with an "eye on federal court," a reference to pending charges in a wild Vallejo kidnapping story.

    After dropping his cell phone in the Dublin home invasion, detectives tracked Muller down and linked him to the March kidnap of  Denise Huskins and Aaron Quinn in Vallejo. Police say the two crimes have several similarities. And the FBI arrested Muller in July. Muller has not been formally charged in the case.

    Meanwhile, Huskins and Quinn filed a claim against the city and police department of Vallejo, alleging they were defamed when police didn't believe they were abducted and ridiculed them in public when Muller was the real kidnapper.

    Muller is expected to appear in federal court in Sacramento as early as Monday in that case. Johnson said he his client will plead not guilty.

    Get the latest from NBC Bay Area anywhere, anytime
    • Download the App

      Available for IOS and Android