NBC Bay Area /

News

Family of Man Killed by BART Police Wants $25M New video surfaces showing chaotic scene

Updated 6:35 PM PDT, Mon, Jan 5, 2009

Related Topics: Shootings | John Burris

30 Comments   Post a comment Post a Comment

BART officials have implied the shooting was an accident, saying the officer's gun discharged while the police officer and four other officers responded to reports that two groups of young men were fighting on a train that had come from San Francisco and was en route to the Dublin/Pleasanton station.

 

Cephus Johnson had tears in his eyes as he recalled the last  text message he would ever send to his 22-year-old nephew.

BART Victim's Family Angry at Investigation

Watch Video

The family of a man shot at a BART station is threatening to sue the agency as protests over the investigation grow.

Man Shot By BART Police

Watch Video

Many questions surround the overnight shooting of a BART rider, by BART police.

Questions Surround BART Shooting

Watch Video

A BART police officer fatally shot an unarmed man on the platform of the Fruitvale Station in Oakland, but BART officials said the details of how the...

"Happy New Year ... I love you," the message sent at 12:49 a.m.  Thursday.

Johnson never received a response.

"I wondered why he didn't text me back, and then I found out why,"  Johnson said.

Oscar Grant III, the best man at Johnson's wedding and known to  his family as being a loving father, a hard worker and a sports enthusiast,  was fatally shot by a Bay Area Rapid Transit police officer at Oakland's  Fruitvale station about an hour after his uncle sent him the text message on  New Year's Day.

BART officers responded to the station to reports of a fight on a  train around 2 a.m. The train Grant was on stopped at the station to let the  officers break up the supposed brawl.

BART Police Chief Gary Gee released a statement today that said,  "On behalf of the BART Police Department and the entire BART organization, we  want to express our condolences to the family of Oscar Grant. I want to  assure Mr. Grant's family and the public that we are taking this  investigation very seriously."

Mario Pangelina, who is the brother of Grant's daughter's mother  and was riding on the same train but two cars behind, said, "There was so  much commotion."

Pangelina and other witnesses said Grant was begging not to get  Tasered because he had a 4-year-old daughter.

"He was not acting hostile," Pangelina said.

Other witnesses said Grant presented no threat to anyone and was  lying on his stomach on the station's platform with his back to the officers  when he was shot.

Then a bullet entered Grant's back and ricocheted to his lung  area, killing him almost immediately, according to John Burris, an Oakland  civil rights attorney who was hired by Grant's family to investigate the  death.

"He was not doing anything of a threatening nature to the  officer," Burris said.

Gee said in the statement, "As frustrating as it is, I want to  stress that we cannot and will not jeopardize this case by discussing details  before the investigation is complete."

He also stated, "This case is not even four days old - we are in  the early stages of the investigation and will do a thorough job."
 
Burris, who has filed numerous lawsuits against police departments  on behalf of family members of those who have been shot and killed by  officers, announced at a news conference today he plans to file a $25 million  lawsuit Monday.

Burris said he will also urge the Alameda County District  Attorney's Office to consider filing criminal charges against the officer who  shot Grant.

Video recordings of the shooting taken by witnesses have since  surfaced, and BART police reportedly confiscated numerous other cell phones  from witnesses that Burris said he believes contain additional footage.

BART officials have said the officer's gun discharged, which  Burris vehemently disagrees with.

"This was an intentional pulling of the trigger," Burris said  today.

Gee's statement said BART investigators are reviewing all evidence  and are cooperating with the Alameda County District Attorney's office, which  is also conducting an investigation.

He asked the public to refrain from jumping to conclusions. He  provided a BART tip line, (877) 679-7000 ext. 7040, and the district  attorney's office general phone number, (510) 272-6222, for anyone who has  evidence or witnessed the incident.

Grant's family has scheduled a memorial service at 11 a.m.  Wednesday at Palma Ceia Baptist Church at 28605 Ruus Road in Hayward.

Copyright Bay City News / NBC Bay Area

Comments (30)

Sort by: Most Recent | Oldest
  • xg Friday, Jan 9 at 9:12 PM FLAG COMMENT i support law enforcement to the fullest, although in this case iam lifting an eyebrow with questions a properly trained officer should know to never ever point the barrel of your gun toward anything you are not willing to kill or destroy. i only saw the video that the news offered and i want to know why did this man have a gun pointed at his back while it appeared he was for the most part complying? i hope to god that additio ... MORE >
  • fed up Wednesday, Jan 7 at 12:15 PM FLAG COMMENT i would like to say that this is a outrage what the problem is these officers are fearing for there lives .... these young men in todays times are lawless and ruthless several officers as well as innocent civilians have been murdered do to reflex ,anger , and terror . yes we have a young man that has lost his life but the issues are waaay deeper than him being murdered and not once has any one mentioned why he had to be restra ... MORE >
  • Anonymous Wednesday, Jan 7 at 12:26 AM FLAG COMMENT Unarmed man shot in the back by a coward,America sux,i`m so thankful i live in australia,it might be a former colonial colony like the USA but we don`t shoot defenceless people in the back! God Save America.
  • leo boyes Tuesday, Jan 6 at 5:34 PM FLAG COMMENT only sergents carry taser so they can shove that excuse
  • Karl Tuesday, Jan 6 at 5:07 PM FLAG COMMENT What a ridiculous comment by Carl. that is a screwed up thing to say about a the story. You are probably some broke joke that is jealous about the $25M lawsuit. I hope some F-ing Bart police kills your mom while shes on the floor.

Post a Comment

Name


Comment - You have 2000 characters left

Enter both words below, separated by a space, in the field located to the lower right. Can't read the words below? Try different words or an audio captcha. What's this?