Controversial Cross to Be Discussed in Appeals Court - NBC Bay Area
East Bay

East Bay

The latest news from around the East Bay

Controversial Cross to Be Discussed in Appeals Court

    processing...

    NEWSLETTERS

    Controversial Cross to Be Discussed in Appeals Court

    A federal judge has ruled that a cross that has been maintained by the Lion’s Club at a public park in Albany for decades is unconstitutional. The battle over whether the cross should stay put will continue Thursday morning when the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in San Francisco will hear arguments on the issue. Pete Suratos reports.

    (Published Thursday, July 18, 2019)

    A federal judge has ruled that a cross that has been maintained by the Lion’s Club at a public park in Albany for decades is unconstitutional.

    The battle over whether the cross should stay put will continue Thursday morning when the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in San Francisco will hear arguments on the issue.

    The controversial cross, which sits on Albany Hill and lights up during Christmas and Easter, is opposed by a group of atheists and city officials who want it removed because it is on public land and doesn’t represent all religions.

    “We want to get the city out of the business of trying to promote one religion over the other,” said Albany Mayor Rochelle Nason. She said it sends the wrong message that Christianity is preferred.

    Appeals Court to Hear Arguments On Albany Cross

    [BAY] Appeals Court to Hear Arguments On Albany Cross

    A cross on public land in Albany has sparked controversy as some argue that it doesn't represent all religions. However, a deal was approved by the city years ago that allowed the Lion's Club to maintain it there.

    (Published Thursday, July 18, 2019)

    The attorney for the Lion’s Club argued that a space was granted to maintain a cross in 1971 and that the city knew the cross was there before the deal was made. A city councilman and his wife sold the land but made an easement deal which allowed the Lion's Club to keep the cross there. The deal was approved by the city years ago. He said the city cannot disregard the easement deal.

    People who use the park are conflicted over the issue. “Times change, things change, the laws change with time. The same thing goes here. It’s not that anybody’s to blame,” said one park user.

    Get the latest from NBC Bay Area anywhere, anytime
    • Download the App

      Available for IOS and Android